On Thursday, Judge Analisa Torres rejected a joint request by Ripple and the SEC to approve a reduced $50 million fine and remove a permanent injunction. She criticized both sides for trying to reverse a final court ruling through a private settlement.
“The Ball Is Back in Our Court”
If the parties “genuinely wish to end the case”, they are now given two options by the court: Ripple and the SEC can either drop their appeals or move forward to appeal her injunction. To this, Ripple’s Chief Legal Officer, Stuart Alderoty, reacted by saying, “The ball is back in our court.”
With this, the ball is back in our court. The Court gave us two options: dismiss our appeal challenging the finding on historic institutional sales—or press forward with the appeal. Stay tuned. Either way, XRP’s legal status as not a security remains unchanged. In the meantime,… https://t.co/edHNbMzYbZ
— Stuart Alderoty (@s_alderoty) June 26, 2025
He made it clear that no matter what they decide, XRP’s legal status remains unchanged, that it is not a security.
Judge Expected Strong Arguments
John Deaton says that Judge Torres pushed back in a way the SEC didn’t expect. He explains that the SEC cited the wrong rule and failed to show any exceptional circumstances to justify changing her earlier decision. Judge Torres said that “the parties haven’t come close” to doing that.
According to Deaton, there is a high bar to meet, and the SEC didn’t clear it. After years of work on the case, the judge was not convinced by the SEC’s sudden request to reduce the fine by 60% and expected a much stronger argument.
Deaton also expected more solid arguments from both sides and admits he underestimated the chances of the judge denying the motion, giving it only a 30% likelihood.
He backed Judge Torres for following the law despite political changes. He said that protecting investors is important, especially in a crypto world full of scams like Celsius, Voyager, BlockFi, and FTX.
Will Ripple SEC Withdraw Their Appeals?
Attorney Fred Rispoli said Ripple and the SEC will likely drop their appeals and settle around $50 million, keeping Judge Torres’ ruling in place. He also added that the SEC may privately or publicly assure Ripple that it won’t face further restrictions, as long as it stays compliant. The court’s injunction will stay in place, but only matters if the SEC chooses to enforce it, which he sees as unlikely.
Read the full article here
